Does Roy Hodgson Need To Beat Leicester City To Save His Job?

1 Posted by - December 10, 2018 - News

To those outside the Palace bubble, it’s perhaps a question that will be a tad surprising but as I sit here writing this on Monday morning, I can’t help but wonder if Roy Hodgson needs to win Saturday’s game against Leicester City to keep hold of his job. 

Yes, the Eagles currently sit two points clear of the relegation zone but with just three league victories in 16 games, it’s fair to ask why a squad with as much individual talent as ours is struggling so badly to generate any sort of positive momentum from week to week. A mere nine days ago, it felt as though the team may have turned a corner after systematically destroying Burnley on our home turf in a 2-0 win, only for the two games which followed to bring us back down to earth with a bang. 

A humbling 3-1 defeat against our south coast rivals Brighton brought howls of derision, only for a 3-2 loss to West Ham on Saturday (having gone 1-0 up early on) to heap more pressure onto Roy Hodgson’s shoulders from a fan-base who were simply desperate to have just one league campaign without the club embroiled in a nerve-shredding battle against the drop. 

You could suggest, as plenty have, that the boss’ hands have been tied somewhat by the club’s transfer activity in recent windows but there is no denying that on paper, the club are blessed with 13 or 14 bonafide Premier League players, leading to questions over why he’s not been able to get much of a tune out of them at all this term. The three wins we have had, have come against the teams currently sat in 17th, 18th and 20th, making Saturday’s clash against the Foxes an important marker for our resilience as a group. 

We will have to face Claude Puel’s men without the services of Wilfried Zaha or James Tomkins after they both picked up their fifth bookings of the season against West Ham and whilst it may seem like an extremely tough task for Roy, the simple fact remains that games and viable opportunities to win them are running out fast. 

If you excuse him a defeat against Jamie Vardy and co. because of the two absences referenced above, we then travel to an away game against Manchester City a week later almost certain of another loss. At that stage, we’ll have won just three times in 18 league games before welcoming Cardiff City to Selhurst Park on Boxing Day for what would be the very definition of a relegation six-pointer. 

It’s tempting to give the gaffer until then to work out the problems we’re currently experiencing but for me, the result and tone of our performance against Leicester will decide whether or not Roy is still in charge for the daunting trip to face Manchester City. So good were we against Sean Dyche’s Burnley that it would have been impossible to sack him, even if we hadn’t won; should we roll over and die as we have in our last two at home to Leicester, I fear the writing will be on the wall for the former England boss. 

It was only a matter of months ago that Roy Hodgson was seen as the saviour of Selhurst Park but football is a truly ruthless sport and unfortunately, the results and performances we’ve put in of late have led to an unavoidable bump in the road. If the players are keen to save the gaffer’s job, they know what they need to do when they next step over the white line. 

HLTCO has no adverts, we cannot survive without your help.


  • Ben December 10, 2018 - 8:08 am Reply

    Have to agree with you HLTCO. What might save him are the few options out there to replace him. Need to be careful or we’ll end up with Mark Hughes in the dugout!!!

  • tzcar December 10, 2018 - 8:18 am Reply

    yes,im sorry roy,s in this situation.i desperately want things to go right for palace,and roy.i can,t help feeling,most of theseproblems evolve fromthe players.hennessay,s mistake on saturday.the free kick against the bar.things just arn,t going right for roy.i don,t know what else he can southampton,the playersMUST LOOK AT THEMSELVES.

  • Rob December 10, 2018 - 9:30 am Reply

    Need a striker.

    If ever there was a time to have brought in Sullay and test him in the premiership it was against Burnley, Brighton and West Ham.

  • Jose Fonte, baby? Jose Fonte, oh, oh, oh December 10, 2018 - 11:37 am Reply

    Whilst we have been abysmal, Ben is right when he says who do we get in? We have had Pulis, Warnack, Pards and Sam. What other firefighters can we get in? Paul Clement and Mark Hughes are the only two available names i can see the board looking at and neither are the sort of manager you’d want in our position.

    The problem is we’ve never had a real plan with managers. Just a series of firefighters and confidence men (with a short De Boer anomaly who was too arrogant and wasn’t given the funding, time or autonomy) to keep us afloat. Until there is a cogent strategy in place, we will continue to be chaotic and dysfunctional. Our current approach to being a BPL club is that of a dog chasing a car.

  • Elbe December 10, 2018 - 4:04 pm Reply

    Its not about Roy, its all about the abysmal transfer deals we have done and the lack of Parish and the staff in seeking out the right players to strengthen the squad,especially in the STRIKER dept.

    Too easy to point the finger at Roy as your article has done.

    If you want to talk about sackings you should look at some of the players who in my opinion either are not good enough or in other cases do not put in a proper shift for the team.

    Lets stop talking about getting rid of Roy and start talking about the January window when with enough pressure on Steve Parish and co we might actually sign THE RIGHT players to deliver for Roy and for us the fans.

  • Eric The Ninja December 11, 2018 - 7:32 pm Reply

    It’s too early to panic.

  • Leave a reply